Whenever a patient dies, the law requires the attending health worker to fill in a cause of death. Sometimes, it’s pretty straightforward but often we find ourselves in a situation where you have to “certify” a patient you know full well should not have died the way they did. Today, I wanna tell their story; their voices, too, must be heard.
Road Trip
One year ago today, a tragic road trip cut short the lives of two best friends. They had purposed to visit Lake Bogoria but were involved in an accident along the Naivasha-Nakuru highway. One died on the spot while the other sustained a bleed in his brain and was rushed by good Samaritans to the nearby Naivasha District Hospital. He needed emergency surgery to relieve the pressure on his brain, failing which he would certainly die. The attending doctor quickly prepared him for the operation and duly informed the theater staff. However, he was told, there was another patient already in theater with a similar injury so he would have to wait for there was only one set of instruments available in the hospital.
A couple of hours later, he finally made it into theater. By this time, he was already in coma and was barely hanging onto life. Following surgery, he was too weak and remained unconscious. Having no ICU facility in the hospital, the surgeon recommended transfer to another center, the nearest options being either Kijabe or Nairobi. Transferring a patient in his condition was no simple task; he required an ambulance with life support equipment so the hospital’s ambulance would not do. Several calls were placed to get one to drive the 30 or so kilometres from Kijabe; by the time it arrived, the young man was no more.
Cause of Death: Severe head injury
The truth: He died because of lack of surgical instruments, he died because there was no ICU ventilator machine, he died because there was no ambulance.
The Young Mother
She was recently married, and was overjoyed when she discovered she would be “sick” for the following 9 months. She tried her best to eat well through the pregnancy, in spite of the constant nausea. She faithfully attended all her clinics and followed the doctor’s instructions to the letter. When the time came for her to deliver, she checked herself into the nearby sub-district hospital to begin her journey into motherhood.
She had a difficult labour, but finally the baby came- a beautiful, bouncing baby girl. Unfortunately,some complications arose in the period immediately following the birth-she wouldn’t stop bleeding (PPH in medspeak). Despite all the medications the doctor prescribed, the bleeding just wouldn’t stop. She had to be taken in for surgery to take out part of her uterus to control the bleeding. The surgery was successful, but she had lost so much blood. Her blood group was at the time unavailable and the hospital administration had to call the regional blood transfusion centre to request for some. The ambulance that would either have taken her to the provincial hospital or gone to collect the blood had just left to transport another patient. She died waiting for a blood transfusion, her newborn child would never know the joy of feeding from her mother’s breast.
Cause of death: Postpartum haemorrhage (PPH)
The truth: She died because of poor policy, she died because blood transfusion services have not been decentralised.
The Medical Officer
Having just completed his internship, he had his whole life ahead of him. He decided to take a break from his workstation in Busia to visit his parents in Kiambu. They had made a lot of sacrifices to get him to this point, it was only natural that he would want to share this news with them. While at home, he fell sick and was diagnosed with malaria at the Kiambu district hospital. A few days later, he developed kidney failure as a complication of the malaria. He needed urgent dialysis; unfortunately these services were not available there and he was immediately referred to the Kenyatta national hospital.
On admission at the KNH, he was immediately put on the wait-list for a dialysis machine. The list was so long, but he had no other choice as he couldn’t afford to be admitted in a private hospital. His medical cover was a measly 1740 Ksh, not even enough to cover the consultation fee at that private facility. He never made it to the top of the list, his kidneys were too far gone.
Cause of death: Acute kidney injury secondary to severe malaria
The truth: He died because the KNH dialysis unit is overstretched, he died because of inadequate resources.
There are so many more stories to tell; only I can’t squeeze them all into this little space. To the friends and families, I say: Kenyan doctors have not forgotten them, their memories will always stay with us. Their memories are what inspire us to want to do better. It is because of these stories that the blue revolution began.
We should always strive to finish what we started; it is my prayer that the blues will not relent until this, too, is done. Here’s to the new year, and a future where doctors will not certify patients because of the shortcomings of the system.
20 responses to “The truth,the whole truth and nothing but the truth”
Posa Aswani
December 29th, 2011 at 13:51
cc morris moses foundation
kubone
December 29th, 2011 at 17:16
was in naivasha last year. met many cases like you’ve described above but ‘we’ tried all we could but ended up like you’ve described above. hope we won’t relent on our cause to improve or even at best totally overhaul this system and not lose ‘saveable’ patients and go home depressed, not because we personally failed, but we did not have what we needed to do the job….. long live the blue revolution!….
daktariwakenya
December 29th, 2011 at 21:01
The blue army shall keep marching on!
freelancegynae
December 29th, 2011 at 17:27
so many experiences come to mind. lost a baby 2 days ago cause no neonatal vent…was sad watching the breath go slow by slow…painful. A colleague lost a patient this morning to PPH…sad….painful. One day we’ll conquer.
daktariwakenya
December 29th, 2011 at 21:01
That day is coming be sure!
beginningsofanenterpreneur
December 30th, 2011 at 05:04
Sad, but a true reflection of what the society has allowed to become a norm..
Dennis Matara
December 30th, 2011 at 06:01
oh dear..
Waci
December 30th, 2011 at 08:13
I agree with you to an extent.
I however see a lot of blame on no instruments, no ambulance, no facilities etc.
What of the cases (which are so many) where the doctor is nowhere to be found when there is a very sick person in the government hospital?
I have seen an accident victim lose blood with nurses trying to save his life as they waited for the doctor in a district hospital. The doctor also needed to release him from hospital-to write the discharge summary. He was so late but we made a lot of noise and moved the patient urgently to KNH, as we left someone waiting for the discharge summary to be written.. Luckily he survived, but how many do?
I have also seen doctors come out so sleepy from their rooms in some wee hours when a child is sick.. I mean, why sleep and claim to be on duty? Please be available when we need you! Sleep during the day, wait for patients at night if you are on night duty!
Yes i agree there are no facilities but i also think doctors need to style up and show up at work when they should, at least earn the pay.
daktariwakenya
December 30th, 2011 at 12:41
I appreciate your sentiments Waci. It’s certainly not a situation you want to find yourself in where the one person who can help you is unavailable. However, I don’t think it’s right to generalise. Every profession has its few bad apples, that’s a fact. It’s also a fact that public hospitals are grossly understaffed. In an ideal setup, the doctor would be able to sleep during the day and work at night. Unfortunately, a large number of our district and sub-district hospitals are run by a single doctor who works day and night, weekends and holidays; and also doubles as administrator. So if they sleep during the day, guess what? The hospital can’t run. Catch-22 situation. Having said that, I think it’s great that citizens like you are speaking up. Hopefully the powers that be will realise how bad things are.
Fiona
December 30th, 2011 at 17:49
Daktari – well said and I like your response to Waci’s comment. Both of you raise pertinent points: professional negligence has a role to play in all professions indiscriminately. However, the medical profession is glaring in that sanctity of human life is at stake for factors grossly beyond simple personal due diligence. Priority has been given to teachers … it’s high time the plight of doctors is given due attention!
Eddie
December 30th, 2011 at 12:52
Ati sleep during the day? You’re kidding .The guy you saw was probably in the 50th hour of a 72-hour long shift.With understaffing in some centres,sleep becomes a luxury where you grab some where you can. You’re being told these things so that you see how badly your taxes and mine have been misappropriated,not climb the moral high-horse and go on a self-righteous trip here!
Melody
December 30th, 2011 at 08:53
T situation in kenya is dire…2 bad we have our prioriyies wrong as a nation..kudos 2 t blue revolution!
kate barasa
December 30th, 2011 at 13:41
Doc i feel you,its so frustrating to helplessly watch a patient l loose a life you could have otherwise done something to save.perhaps we cut down on the number of seminars to equip the hospitals.
Secondly on shortage of staff why post Drs as DMOHS to spent alot of their time wasting their skills,instead of treating patients they do ignoble things like ‘repeatedly repairing ladies toilets’.Ambrose thumbs up, wish we had more with a heart for patients like you!
daktariwakenya
December 30th, 2011 at 14:12
Thanks Kate; just wondering-who is Ambrose??
kate barasa
December 30th, 2011 at 16:28
A committed Dr on whose wall i these truths
Kigen
December 30th, 2011 at 15:44
I can share the experience of the frustration that Kenyan healthcare workers face when serving their clients. It is not only doctors who face the inconvenience. I am a RN and have witnessed people lose life not because there was nobody to help, but just because the equipment urgently needed was ‘missing’, ‘broken’ or ‘waiting to be fixed.’ In June 2009, while working as an intern (Nursing Officer) in (pediatric) ward six at the PGH Nakuru, three children, all of them under one year, died because the ventilator was broken. It was Friday, I was on night duty; with the lives of 10 babies depending on a single tank of oxygen. We had to improvise: One tank, no standard pediatric mask or ventilators. So we took tubes from IV infusion sets, taped them on to the main connector from the tank, and prayed to God that ALL the 10 babies required the same rate of flow. If you are a medic, you know too well that oxygen is as essential as it is harmful: if given too much, it can lead to complications; too little, one becomes hypoxic. For three hours, all was fine. Then the tank ran out at 2 AM. The other tank had no regulator, and the other ventilator (concentration pump) was broken, unusable. The maintenance personnel tried to improvise a regulator from another tank but it did not work. Meanwhile, very sick babies were gasping…dying. By 6 AM three had lost the fight. Cause of death: complications of hypoxia. Truth: lack of ventilation equipment.
The scene keeps playing in my memory over and over, and the pain of seeing the mothers of the three babies mourn has remained with me ever since. In such circumstances, who hears the voice of the helpless citizens who cannot afford to take their loved ones to private, more equipped institutions? Who will save the lives of innocent children from the rogue (government) healthcare system which does not care?
daktariwakenya
December 30th, 2011 at 15:53
Thanks for sharing your story Kigen;so sad…let’s all purpose to be the voice of the voiceless.
kate barasa
December 30th, 2011 at 16:33
A committed Dr on whose wall i read about these truths
daktariwakenya
January 2nd, 2012 at 12:37
Oh,ok..please thank Ambrose on my behalf
Afro Chic
December 30th, 2011 at 17:49
Kuddos to the blue collar revolution! One patient at a time. Let’s keep the hope and the prayers alive. By all means, let’s keep the voices of the ‘voiceless’ loud and clear….the echoes will resonate to the right ears.